Pumpkin Spice (Wonder Flavors) 3.5% (4-30-25) – This one will be an odd one for me, as it has some issues, but I think it can be fixed in the mix. The biggest off note was a fairly present earthy tone, persisted throughout, with an almost acrid dry finish. Spice(s) were fairly high and almost distracting at times, (nutmeg primarily, clove ?). Even with those deficits I think this could actually be covered up in mixes fairly easily, but that’s a guess. 3.5% pretty strong, with just below mid-level sweet was good. It’s odd that I would rate something high(er) even with some fairly present off-notes. Perhaps more for what it COULD be, than what it is. 9/10.